Supreme Court Hearing on SIR: Article 324 Grants ECI Control Over Electoral Rolls, Argues Rakesh Dwivedi

The Supreme Court’s hearing on Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has thrown a spotlight back onto the Election Commission of India (ECI) and its constitutional powers.

In court, senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi didn’t mince words—

he argued that Article 324 gives the ECI full authority over how electoral rolls are prepared and revised.

Article 324 really sits at the heart of all this.

Dwivedi stood up for the ECI, saying Article 324 lets the Commission oversee, guide, and control every part of the election process—

including the all-important job of updating electoral rolls.

In his view, this isn’t just a technical detail.

It’s the foundation that keeps elections free and fair,

and it protects the ECI from outside interference.

He pushed the point that you can’t separate managing the voter list from actually running the election—

it’s all one constitutional responsibility, right in the ECI’s hands.

So, what exactly is SIR?

The Special Intensive Revision is the ECI’s way of keeping the voter list clean—removing names that shouldn’t be there, and adding those that should. The Supreme Court got involved because people raised questions about how and when the ECI runs these revisions, especially in some regions.

Petitioners wondered if these revisions might mess with people’s right to vote. But Dwivedi fired back, insisting that SIR is a legally sound process, designed to keep the voter rolls accurate and honest.

The Supreme Court dug into the constitutional setup that governs elections.

The judges recognized how important Article 324 is for empowering the ECI, but they also made it clear—there has to be a balance between the Commission’s authority and protecting voters’ rights.

This hearing matters. It could spell out exactly where the ECI’s powers begin and end, and set the rules for how future voter list updates are handled.

Why does any of this matter to the average person?

Simple. The Court’s decision on SIR will shape India’s elections for years to come. A clear reading of Article 324 could boost the ECI’s independence, while keeping the voter registration process transparent and fair.

Stay updated on Supreme Court hearings, constitutional matters, and election-related news.Follow our website for real-time legal updates and in-depth analysis.